Political Autoimmune Disorders and Collapse of Civilizations

Grey’s Arch, Red River Gorge, Kentucky

It’s the day after election day in the U.S., and the results have been discouraging. If you actually believe the Democrats, they are going to sweep in and fix all the flaws in the Trump administration, which they call fascist, by doing all sorts of truly fascist things like putting everyone whom they want to finger in jail. Biggest among these ostensible perps, in the eyes of the Ds, is Elon Musk, whose primary sin has been in being too successful in actually starting industries that are paradigm shifting. This is classic Tribal behavior, and I discuss this in detail in the piece prior to this one. It’s just incomprehensible at this End of Elite Overproduction that one mode of ending the internecine violence might be to create more, better things. That doesn’t work in the status-based mindset.

And look — Ii’s not that the Trump administration hasn’t had its share of defects of corruption — it certainly has. The problem with the Ds, though, is the constant undermining of the notion of anyone other than their select coterie of Bolsheviks should have any power. And we all know from history how that ends (spoiler alert for the historically illiterate — millions of people die.)

The problem with all this is that, for some reason/stage of psychosocial development that I haven’t completely figured out, is that all the strategies for action being advanced by the D’s Praetorian guard, are projected onto the Republicans. As I said above, the Rs at this particular moment in time, in terms of actual sins, are more the standard garden-variety corrupt politicians. But normal corrupt politician sins are not what the avant-garde Ds have in mind. So when they accuse the Republicans of being fascist, they’re giving a darker window into their collective id. And hey – if the Republicans were really fascists, they would have rounded up all the Democrats and shot them all. And all that talk about the Republicans suspending elections would have already occurred. Nothing of the sort has happened, and more as a display of erratic political will, Trump has already said he wants to work with the Democratic leadership, and by the way, did you know the stock market is up?

Somewhere in the somewhat recent past, a person appropriated the medical term ‘autoimmune disorder’ to describe our politics. What is an autoimmune disease? An autoimmune disease is when your immune system attacks healthy cells in your body. The standard issue versions are rheumatoid arthritis and lupus. In the political/v-Meme context, it’s when an infective agent uses your values to attack and destroy your system of social organization. A great example of that would be the situation I described above. Democrats are using free speech to attack the Republicans, calling them fascist, while essentially gaslighting the public to believe that the Republicans are authoritarians. They are counting on people’s natural moral sense to view the Democratic accusation as somehow justifiable, since we live in an ostensibly rational society. This is intended to cause some revulsion reaction in the general body politic that will relationally disrupt their sense of belonging with the current administration. But it’s without basis. Like I said — if Trump was really Literally Hitler, they’d all be dead. Instead, none of the worst are dead at all. They just LOOK like they’re dead. See the photo below of Connecticut Representative/Poison Frog Rosa DeLauro.

But when you listen to their thought leaders, it’s pretty clear what they want to do to the Republicans. Here’s an interview clip with Kara Swisher, a former tech reporter, who has gone all in on the personality psychopath angle.

A perfect example of an autoimmune political virus at work. Swisher’s words, at least, are scary — but the idea is straightforward — use the principles of justice in a liberal republic to go after those she views as enemies. Big Balls was tasked to participate in DOGE, the task force created by Trump, to go after corruption. For his participation in this, Swisher wants him in jail.

It gets worse. Hillary Clinton, otherwise known as an incarnated Demon from the 8th Level of the Inferno, shares air time with Swisher’s fantasy here.

Once again, it is using the systems inside a liberal democratic republic to wage war against the body politic, with the unstated intent of collapse. Positively psychopathic.

We are currently seeing a new wave of Muslim politicians who are also playing the same autoimmune card. The Islamic faith in any fundamental interpretation is profoundly at odds with the notion of a liberal democracy, that is built on a foundation of individual rights, and processes that clearly divide church and state. Additionally, there are a whole panoply of mullah-sanctioned offenses that would lead to literal execution if we followed Islamic law — such as stoning of homosexuals and adulterers.

But let’s back off the more dramatic vectors for Islamic autoimmune disorder. Let’s move away from women, and onto issues with animals. Forget the whole deal around pigs and bacon — dogs are a much larger level for social control in a Western society. According to some interpretations of the Quran, dogs are unclean, and in order for some Muslims to feel “safe” in society, dogs must be removed from public spaces in order to “respect their religion.” The recent media stream has seen quite a bit going on about the sacrilegious effects of dog saliva – an obvious trigger for some kind of appropriate revulsion reaction, as well as firing up their OCD partners on the other side of the Tribal v-Meme. This whole thing is legit, amirite?

The accommodation that will be sought, though, will be more banning, of course, and strict leash laws, with punishment. Why does this matter? Dog parks are one of the few places I’ve been to in the last ten years where I could actually talk to random people and build friendships. I don’t have young children any more, and if you’re not clubbing or on the PTA, you’re sorely limited in meeting people. Regular parks already have been wrecked for social connection due to homelessness, as well as general paranoia. Imagine me, a 64 year old man, approaching a young woman with a child, and telling them I want to be their neighbor. ‘Nuf said..

But dogs change that. Dogs don’t care who’s butt they sniff as long as they are friendly butts. This inevitably leads to conversations.

And, as we know, the group that finds this most reprehensible is the Islamic contingent, though Chinese people with OCD are also up there. They breed into their children a fear of dogs, even though kids naturally want to pat dogs. Muslim parents are actually fighting an uphillKids are also bombarded with images in the media of dogs being cute things that like kids and want to be petted. So those Muslim parents have some uphill work to do.

And the situation is also exacerbated by other autoimmune societal influencers. There is a powerful movement in the dog world that you shouldn’t own a dog that is not a rescue from a shelter. But in more toxic communities, like where I used to live (Moscow ID/Pullman WA) some percentage of the rescues were pit bull and pit bull crosses trucked up from southern CA shelters specializing in rescuing dogs from houses subject to drug busts. A large percentage of these dogs are actually un-remediable, and will bite. Not exactly the kind of dog you want off leash. The percentage of pit bulls in the pet population will directly influence people’s rational fears about getting bitten.

Where I live now, there are only a few, and most of these are on the leash. But regardless, because we’re at that point of societal devolution, no one would think of dog agency as something to be managed. And what THAT means is the owners of dogs with high bite potential would never muzzle their dogs — an easy solution. Muzzling your dog would be a huge status decrement, and would detract from the fact that you are superior to the people went out and bought a particular breed for specific characteristics. It would also send a parallel signal that you mapped to one’s hatred for any kind of cultural or dog breed relativism. You are no better than me with your well-trained purebred borzoi that will come from a mile away to your whistle. It is a weird form of White Guilt, eloquently described by Eli and Shelby Steele, in their latest eponymously named documentary. Pit bull lives matter!

The result is an amazing example of how a political autoimmune disease affects a particular niche of society, with repercussions. Loosely enforced leash laws, which really are ‘leash heuristics’ turn into societal connection destroyers. No one who doesn’t know a person already is going to walk up to another person with a dog on a leash and walk alongside them. Relational mixing is broken down, in the name of “respecting their religion.” Worse, on my way out the door from my last gig, I believe I had a preliminary Title IX complaint filed against me because I took my dogs to class for a “petting day”. As weird as this may sound, this was also a way of enforcing status-based authoritarianism already rife in the university environment. When the former president’s wife (called the First Lady!) was active, she had a pair of corgis who honestly spread joy to lots of students. I was considered acting beyond my station by doing the same. In case you missed it, Americans love dogs, and the kids in my class would eagerly grab onto my border collies for selfies and pats.

But there goes that autoimmune disease thing again — using a set of values (respect for someone’s religion) as a vehicle to shut down social connection and be part of a larger societal devolution. And yes — Islam is rife with that. Kathy Hochul wearing a hijab. It’s not hard to find examples.

The problem is once they’re in charge, that sense of plurality goes out the window, pronto. Forget the whole ‘life joy’ angle. As I’ve said, Big A Authoritarians need a lack of joy/depression mode for a majority of the population to have a functioning authority-driven social structure.

The wild thing is that you don’t have to look far afield to find actual Muslim countries that constrain the Muslim faith. Most of the central Asian ‘stans’ restrict the Azan — the Muslim call to prayer. There are other restrictions as well. It’s not hard to figure out which ones — look at native dress for women. Short version — if they are allowed to show their hair, the governments have realized some form of separation and control of religion. They may not be as “evolved” as our own government, with its bans on religious restrictions. But they also recognize fundamentalist Islam is problem. The mullahs issue fatwas for the religion, and functionally form the governments where they’re allowed to. The secular, but far more authoritarian states, realize that mind-fucking/auto-immune political viruses are real. And at some level, they inoculate themselves against them. You can badger your wife in your own home to wrap her hair up. But outside, she’s got freedom whether you like it or not. And more importantly, OTHER old women aren’t allowed to enforce these edicts.

Another factor, because of the power of religious authority in Muslim societies, and makes Islam particularly problematic, because there is no really evolutionary possibility for Islam in the context of psychosocial evolution. You can’t get to any real personal agency because you have the mullahs waving the Quran. And so, not surprisingly, we can see entire belts of nations, particularly in the Arab world, that are stuck. And thanks to our own government, that took out the secular aspirational leadership in places like Libya (not like these places didn’t have problems before, folks) we now have, in the 21st Century, slave markets. All endorsed by Islam. Sometimes, the autoimmune disease destroys the host.

The problems also occur when you have competitive autoimmune diseases who both are working on overwhelming the current systems of restraint. Once again — by using the liberal societies’ moral codes against it. These opposing forces are fine with co-opting these value sets, and even supporting others at the same psychosocial developmental level until they get control. Then, once control is achieved, they will turn on each other. All of these are relationally devolutional/psychopathic control strategies, so as long as there are lines in the sandbox that separate them enough, they will play well together, until they’ve destroyed the higher v-Meme host. And then you better believe all Hell is going to break loose. Nothing is more emblematic of this than the whole ‘Free Palestine’ movement being supported by the whole LGBTQ+ Poison Frog movement, who have decided to collaborate (often at a distance) with the Islamic community. The Muslim contingent of the Free Palestine movement, being fundamentalist, would have no patience if they ever gained control for purple-haired and nose-pierced lesbians, who have adopted totemic superficial symbols that allow easy identification.

It’s easy to pick on Islam, but you don’t have to go far psychosocially to realize that this is an aggregate development/cultural issue. The grooming gang scandal in the UK is mostly a Pakistani concoction, and a classic example of how an autoimmune disorder is unraveling a society in the wildest way possible. Legitimizing a lack of criticism because of racism of organized gangs literally raping tens of thousands of underage girls is how you destroy a society.

Likewise, making it a hate crime if a person refuses to use a trans-person’s pronouns. That’s another autoimmune disease. Why? When you extract all agency out of a society for a person to correctly relationally define themselves adjacent to someone else, you’re essentially banning a person from being rational. Surrendering that ability is what makes a liberal democracy possible. And so the devolutionary trend begins. The MAIN structure of an advanced, high trust society goes in the toilet.

The same thing has happened in the context of the various DEI campaigns. What happens is not that the body politic doesn’t recognize that it has an autoimmune disorder. It’s that there are warping reactions that occur in society to get away from it, as elites in a society use social status and money to move to more normal and normative means of relating. I’ll never forget a couple of summers ago touring the wine country in the Willamette Valley. We stopped at a particularly swanky winery — Chateau Serene — for a tasting. They had a complex gating system to get in, and even after that, a glass of wine cost $32. You better believe there wasn’t a minority in the place. And even in the heart of the Islamic Republic of Iran, I’ve seen pictures of women hoisting a martini while NOT wearing the hijab. Elites will find a way to be cosmopolitan.

There’s a continuing list of psychosocial autoimmune diseases – things like chronic protests against the viability of the USA as being a reasonable country. Using free speech to hijack societal devolution is a standard. I’d encourage you to make your own list. Key elements are, of course, constantly tearing down present society with no constructive solutions, along with the consequential outcome of chaos and anarchy — all collapse vectors. Drugs and facilitation given to addicts, instead of enforced treatment — that would be a big one. Turning over libraries to homeless people in the name of “compassion”. Centering the freedom of the mentally ill — that would be a prime collapse narrative and a great example of a psychosocial autoimmune disease. Decreasing the window of tolerance for things that provide some kind of normative joy. Even incidental versions that are inconsequential — banning peanuts on airplane flights. The refusal to clean up government programs from corruption, as has happened in places like Minneapolis, MN, because of potential discrimination of the Somali community. What an autoimmune disease that is!

The first step towards fixing any of this is to recognize it. Here’s the blueprint. Now I gotta go play with my dogs in a public space. Boo Boo’s got some squirrels to hunt. Off leash. While I can.

Is Michelle Obama a Man? (and other psychopathic double-binds)

Boo Boo on a fine summer day

One of the sort-of humorous Internet memes bouncing around in the noosphere is the allegation that Michelle Obama, wife of President Barack Obama, is a transgender male -> female. I don’t particularly take any of it seriously. While I think Barack Obama was actually a terrible President, and accelerated an era in US politics of active deception, I don’t think his wife is a dude. As the Joker would say, “Even for me, that’s cold.”

But it’s still an interesting problem. And a classic example of what is called a ‘double bind’ — a process of psychopathic manipulation used to establish control over people through channeling interpretation through a person looking to dominate a circumstance. I went to ChatGPT for a more normative definition, and this is what the AI said. I don’t use AI much in writing, but this is expository.

“A psychopathic double bind is not a formal diagnosis or recognized term in psychology. It’s a descriptive phrase that combines the ideas of a double bind (from Gregory Bateson) with the interpersonal tactics often associated with psychopathic or highly manipulative personalities.

A useful working definition would be:

A psychopathic double bind is a situation deliberately engineered by a manipulative person in which every available response carries a negative consequence, allowing the manipulator to maintain control, create confusion, or justify further exploitation regardless of what the other person does.

Several features distinguish it from an ordinary double bind:

  • Intentionality. A classic Batesonian double bind can arise unintentionally in dysfunctional families or organizations. A psychopathic double bind is typically constructed on purpose.
  • Asymmetrical benefit. The manipulator benefits no matter which option the victim chooses.
  • Moral inversion. The victim is made to appear guilty, incompetent, or disloyal regardless of their decision.
  • Escape prevention. Attempts to point out the contradiction become further evidence that the victim is “the problem.”

General structure

The manipulator creates two incompatible demands:

  • If you do A, you are condemned for A.
  • If you do B, you are condemned for B.
  • If you refuse to choose, that refusal is itself treated as wrongdoing.

This produces a “heads I win, tails you lose” dynamic.”

The case of “is Michelle Obama a man?” is a classic example of this type of thinking.

  1. If you believe Michelle Obama is a man, it means in a given circumstance that she is to be valorized for being “stunning and brave.” Not only was she the First Lady of the United States, she was the first Trans First Lady!
  2. But of course, we certainly recognize that unless you are in the correct, unplaceable and impossible context, what you’re really saying if you attempt to point out the bulge in Michelle’s trousers, you are actually attacking her femininity, and also declaring her a fraud for having produced (ostensibly) two daughters.

Which it is depends on the manipulation the psychopath wants to use to subordinate your status. I personally think the Michelle Obama situation is borderline ridiculous, because I am not a psychopath. But one of the interesting things I did notice in my teaching career was that any declaration of any race or ethnic category by an older white male (myself) was treated as a racial slur by the class in general, but by the white students in specific. You were supposed to be racially blind, even if you were attempting to move a particular underrepresented minority towards a job opportunity where people were implementing a DEI strategy to increase minority representation.

This was particularly vexing for me because I have a long history of coaching primarily Hispanic students from extremely poor backgrounds, with no professional representation in their immediate family. The actual Mexican or Mexican-American kids had no problem with me standing up and telling them I was available for career consultation (the standard circumstance I’d do for my divination) but as time went on, it became instantiated as a slur if I said it. I was once accused of racism by a group of white students for attempting to wheedle a bag of Christmas tamales from some Mexican-American students I was helping. Do note that THEY thought it was funny. But they also knew their abuelita’s tamales were the real thing.

What this implies is that minority students in a classroom environment, especially if backed by white female students, could have a pocket veto on the professor in a class, as long as that professor was white and male. They would be backed up by a university’s Compliance and Civil Rights office, often in a criminally nonsensical fashion. Though no punishment could ever be meted out for declaring something that we were basically required to divine on our grant applications, that did not stop the institution from basically commissioning their own version of Stasi to create a psychopathic control environment toward speech and interaction with students.

Why did they do this? Now we get back to the N/S axis of civilization. If a university can get a professor to police their own speech, then the institution doesn’t have to. But what it also did was create an environment where the professor/student relationship was also severed, especially if the professor was white, and the student was from a minority or a women student. No one was winning. But that was the point. Do note you can keep going with this, into the domain of Manipulative Reproductive Suppression. By recruiting more poor students, but then disallowing them the mentorship to succeed, which will, dollars to donuts, be provided by older white faculty, you’re still getting your Elite Overproduction goals met of alternately recruiting students into degree programs and taking up slots so that the elites end up having to compete against less students when it really matters – at the end of the line when getting jobs. Wild how that works.

The other interesting part of the phenomenon was if one considered the dichotomy of Independently Generated, Trust-Based Relationships (of which action-drive friendships are a subclass) and Externally Defined, Title-driven relationships, what the entire movement did was place control of those definitions in the hands of the psychopathic clique. That meant that an entire psychopathic contingent could disallow friendships (you can only approach a person XXX ethnicity with a phony script generated by the psychopaths) and only allow, at best, awkward and unfulfilling attachment among the obedient populace. Literally saying that the only relationships that were allowed to exist were under Sauron’s eye. And defined by Sauron himself. Which also develops the training materials that HR forces down everyone’s throat.

So which is it? Is Michelle Obama a dude? If you’re in the outgroup, like Mrs. Robinson, any way you look at this you lose.

Psychopathic Meta-Strategies — What happens when you combine DEI, Manipulative Reproductive Suppression (MRS), and Elite Overproduction?

Kelly Creek Hoodoos, Clearwater National Forest, Idaho

One of the most striking examples of psychopathic meta-strategies has been the transformation of Diversity, Equity and Inclusion (DEI) into a tool of relational disruption. Through a process of endless refinement of sophistication, DEI has turned from “I believe I should recognize my biases and give people who are different than me a chance to be my friend” to a wholesale institutional shift towards low empathy, externally defined relationships. And that, of course, has led to the destruction of an independently generated, rational relational environment, to a set of belief structures used by psychopaths to adaptively break down society.

But how that actually has happened depends on which demographic group of psychopathic actors developed sophisticated meta-strategies to achieve their end goals. In the era of Elite Overproduction, where our modern society has produced too many elite children for too few seats at the elite table, it is women that have dominated the psychopathic milieu. There are many roles for these individuals that have been discussed in detail on this blog (Immiserators, for example, as well as Propagators of policy), as well as chronic luxury-belief holders and virtue signalers which are dominated by AWFULs (Affluent White Female Urban Liberals) .

How all this happened really depends, though, on a time-dependent perspective. The negative aspects didn’t always used to create the society we live in today. Things change. I was one of the university leaders in DEI back in the ’90s, working on bringing Hispanic kids into engineering education from the Yakima Valley. I can’t say I practiced any layered moral calculus like I discuss in this piece in my efforts. I liked Mexican-Americans (still do) , wanted to learn Spanish, and if I picked up a girlfriend and some of her abuela’s tamales along the way, what was not to like? I ended my career as a professor with lots of tamales, no Hispanic girlfriend, but lots of Mexican and Mexican-American students whom I am still fond of. I’d also argue that there was plenty of room at the professional table for more engineers, though definitely much fewer spots now.

Hence the influence of elite overproduction. As my career advanced, and time marched on, available spots in engineering became less and less. Now, even in a field like mechanical engineering, which is about as general an engineering discipline as a society can have, there are far fewer seats at the table. Which then directly influences the Elite Overproduction Musical Chairs game. Elites never expected there to not have enough engineering slots — so it was a full court press merely to contain salary inflation, which then morphed into the current disaster involving the disordered H1B program.

This is where things get complicated. As aggregate elite slots declined some 25 years ago, it’s not clear to me that the current elite actors were aware of the potential for salary collapse among their children. Further, it seemed like the actual discrimination against minorities was profoundly on the wane. So it became safe, and potentially lucrative to trumpet causes like DEI. You could achieve virtue points on your social credit score and not be affected by any of it (a classic function of luxury beliefs), while absorbing many of these ostensibly aggrieved minorities in newly established university bureaucracies. No one would dream of making anyone other than an African-American individual as a VP of Minority Affairs, regardless of his or her relative competence. And at the beginning of the whole DEI, there were plenty of suppressed, qualified minority candidates available. The analysis of the framework seemed to hold up — discrimination HAD indeed delayed career advancement in minorities. As someone there watching it, AND participating in building our student body around this principle, it all made sense.

But there were signs. When I started recruiting Hispanic students out of the Yakima Valley, I noticed an interesting phenomenon. All the very top students (high SAT/GPA) had been snatched up by institutions like MIT. We were left at my state land-grant institution with the secondaries, who were still pretty good. But not the top by a long shot. These students, even going to a school like WSU, struggled, and required additional programs to make sure they could get through.

As Elite Overproduction progressed, this created an interesting signal inside the system. It is fair, and safe to say, white male advancement started being unfairly targeted and decremented post-2000. This created a vacuum in qualified candidates for many positions. As a result, more ostensible minorities (mostly white women) started making up the preferred hiring demographic. In the case of universities, their bureaucracies expanded, now being filled more with white women than any other group. And that group were far more likely to be filled with women WITHOUT children. And in any group like that, they were vastly overrepresented by lesbians. LGBTQI+ is championed in universities for reasons. It is protected caste politics at its worst.

At the beginning, the reason for this might be attributed to various conscious social and suppressive (even diabolical) policies and strategies. But I really don’t think so. I think that what happened was a natural demographic cascade. Those were the hiring strategies, no one had thought much about the downstream effects, and things just happened.

But what happens when you group aggrieved minorities together, and then deplete the actual capital available for moving into elite ranks, is you end up with a rising tide of virtue signaling and luxury beliefs. And THAT was then responsible for the growth of the Immiseration class and the persecutorial environment that we now see inside of universities.

Now couple this with a society increasingly unable to provide enough Musical Chairs seats for the children of women who were either already members of elites wanting their children to be elites, or aspirational elites from minorities, seeking “the American Dream” for their own progeny. It was literally a moment in time of “let the games begin!” And the games were relationally disruptive meta-strategies by multiple seekers attempting to get their children ahead. Enter Stage Left Manipulative Reproductive Suppression (MRS).

Here is a list of some of those strategies.

  1. Get other people to not have kids in the first place, through discouragement of feminine chastity, ubiquity and destigmatizing abortion, as well as strategies such as delayed marriage and loss of fertility as being somehow “wiser” than having a child at a younger age.
  2. Encourage interracial dating and marriage as a supreme sign of virtue. Interracial and intercultural relationships are far more difficult than marrying within your own racial or social group, so when you encourage this, you are inherently putting your thumb on the scales for lack of reproductive success. If you doubt this is being held up as a paragon, look at the ad feed before any sporting event.
  3. Support DEI in elite institution admissions. Women looking to lower the competition for their own children would look to recruit students from underrepresented minorities because on average, those kids from the lower societal caste would lack the social coding necessary to compete in elite job markets post-graduation. Short version — would you rather have your kids competing against 100 other White/Asian kids from prepared backgrounds, or would you rather have them competing against 50 White/Asians, and 50 from scattered, underqualified minorities who managed to barely limp through the curriculum?
  4. Support elimination of modestly objective intelligence measurements like the SAT so that the incoming college classes could be constituted with under qualified students, and protected by virtue signaling regarding racism if they didn’t come up to the bar.

The list goes on. But what was NOT anticipated is that these strategies would prove so destructive that they would potentially COLLAPSE the institutions the elites required to assert their own elite status in the job market. As a signal around this, we are now seeing a wave of messaging around the theme “should all kids go to college?” The answer is obviously no, but the strategy of going to college was sold so hard, to the detriment of both under qualified minorities as well as elite co-competitors, it’s literally attempting to back away from the precipice while the ground crumbles underfoot.

There is a short-term upside to sabotaging other people’s children’s success – resources that the sabotaged child brings to the table are real, and those resources can be made to flow to elites. A great example is tuition dollars in colleges that are spent in lower level mass classes that are revenue generators for every university out there. In our own university, we had one student who had taken Calculus 1 six times! And I can guarantee that the cost of that student’s education was far less than a student in an upper division elective. So essentially that student’s student loans (non-dischargeable in bankruptcy) were feeding students up the chain of command — as well as the senior administrative caste salaries, also increasingly dominated by women in general, and lesbians in particular.

The problem is the lack of societal benefit. Elites would be raking in the cash (and they have been) but the long term is the investment depends on harnessing lower-caste students to nondischargeable debt, essentially making them indentured servants.

What this means is one can start understanding the whole late-stage DEI mechanism as another strategy, driven by MRS, leading first to institutional collapse (people are figuring out that college is not going to get their kids into the elite caste) but if maintained long enough, societal collapse.

And what people fail to acknowledge is that MRS is inherently a Matriarchal Societal Strategy. Though implicit, women, through luxury beliefs and virtue signaling are controlling relational formation and destruction in society.

AND — matriarchal structures, who have had their praises sung as part of MRS, also lead to collapsing birth rates inside their home societies. And here’s the unpleasant, psychopathic rub. That collapse then leads to rape, and the return/pre-eminence of a degenerate patriarchal society. Anyone that doubts this can look to the rape gang catastrophe happening now in Great Britain, and driven by the immigrant South Asian sub-caste, primarily from Pakistan.

All of this returns to the title of this piece — which is a psychopathic meta-strategy with reinforcing societal loops. It’s sort of a societal anesthesia and autoimmune disorder which allows the destruction of core relational scaffolding — the family unit — that will allow temporary control of an elite overclass.

But in the end, it will all come tumbling down.

Editorial Note: I want to make it very clear that two of the subclasses of intellectual thought in all this have been developed and championed by Dr. Rob Henderson and Dr. Dani Sulikowski, who have respectively written extensively on luxury beliefs, and Manipulative Reproductive Suppression. I’ve linked to my work that describes their contributions, and have actively promoted their work. It is far more accessible, and data-supported than my own (it’s the problem when you go bigger picture) and needs far greater dissemination. Rob has a Substack that I support as well. Dr. Dani can be found on X at @DrDaniS. I also recommend reading Peter Turchin’s work, which I also use.

Immigration as a Psychopathic Boundary Attack

In the Welsh countryside

Two days ago, there was a videotaped attempted beheading by a Sudanese illegal immigrant in North Belfast, Ireland. The event, which involved gouging the eye with a knife of a local Belfast resident, followed by the perpetrator attempting to saw off the head of the individual. The act has caused explosive riots across Northern Ireland.

The official census in Northern Ireland is taken in the years 2011, 2021, with the next official census taken in 2031. From 2021 to 2021, though, the population of ostensible asylum seekers from Muslim countries, primarily from Syria and the Sahel (Somalia, Sudan, etc.) has tripled, and continues to increase. Both these areas feature populations that are decidedly non-assimilative. The Syrians are obviously Arabic in feature, and the the Somalia/Sudan contingent are obvious Africans. They would stick out like a sore thumb in Belfast, which is white, Anglo-Saxon stock. Consulting various AI platforms, like ChatGPT and Claude, offers little elite sympathy for the natives, who historically have been economically marginalized. Additionally, the AIs give a story that attempts to distract from the obvious cultural influences around the various murders and rapes that have originated from the Muslim community. Similar to the grooming gang scandals, these resettlement efforts are recast into bigotry and hatred against immigrants AFTER a given incitement (such as the attempted beheading) occurs.

Immigration of this type is never in the interest of the lower class/caste groups that are expected to absorb these different groups. As I’ve mentioned in a previous piece, immigration applies pressure to availability of lower income housing, as well as economic opportunities, elevated crime rates and such. Various Collapse Narratives – stories told by elites wanting to drive collapse- are inevitably spun by the press regarding these types of immigrant groups, almost always in a positive light. But the obvious reality is that had those people not been imported into the country, that particular crime would not have occurred. And things become even more problematic when one considers that there are critical mass cultural sizes for non-assimilation of given populations, that are actually shrinking due to technology by the year. As the child of an immigrant myself, I can attest that my own father would call back to Iran once every 2-3 years, for a weeping and wailing session that would last at most 30 minutes. Anyone with an iPhone can reach anyone anywhere in the world through WhatsApp for hours on a daily basis. Why get to know your neighbors at all?

The problem as well, at least in the Northern Ireland situation, is also the differential treatment of women inside Islamic cultures. Women are obviously far more constrained inside Islamic culture, and especially inside fundamentalist Islamic communities, because the women themselves are the primary enforcers and immiserators against younger women. But the deeper problem inside the Matrix is not Islam itself. It’s the fact that the Islamic faith pairs perfectly, in its persecution of women, with the desires of white females inside the British and Irish governments to conduct pogroms of manipulative reproductive suppression against other potential white offspring, who may have the cultural coding to advance in society. Perusing X today, there were the usual voices condemning the nominal “far right” in perpetrating violence in the wake of the beheading from the masculine side. But front and center were women, armed with the same message, not decrying the violence perpetrator — the Sudanese dude that attempted to saw off his victim’s head.

Quite the opposite. These women were attacking alpha males inside their own immediate community — their potential defenders — for assuming a rational posture against a culture that promotes decapitation as a way of conducting civic discourse.

Saying this is obviously an explosive take. But the shift in v-Meme perspective regarding condemning the people being attacked is emergent in the structure of any argument that must be made. The higher virtue-signaling moral ground, at least in these white women’s mind, must be held by decrying violence, because the position itself is what I’ve named a Collapse Narrative, and inherently irrational and ungrounded. In a healthy community, once an obvious threat was established, the leadership would move to neutralize an individual, or a contingent of individuals who assumed that the right path was beheading of adversaries. Especially if there was deeper cultural context. Not this bunch.

I put this up on X earlier today, that I thought was quite succinct, in the difference between an irrational fear, which racism is used as a moral status-assertion mechanism, and a rational fear, where grounding evidence indicates the potential is real and demonstrated.

This is a hard issue to unpack. It has Survival v-Meme level implications, in that once you admit a certain critical mass of individuals into your country who are at the Tribal v-Meme levels, such as the Somalis, you can’t easily just send them back. But they are indeed an invading army, and are being used as such in the current milieu — amazingly enough, by women, using them against other women and their children in this period of Elite Overproduction. It’s also no surprise that elite women in that society are more than happy to wage war against their own perceived adversaries — high-T males who are acting nominally along the course of protect-and-provide for their own communities. And the women doing so have no problem enlisting beta males, who populate most institutions, in triangulating institutional authority against those selfsame alpha males.

One of the most interesting psychosocial aspects of all of this is that once a non-assimilative immigrant population grows to a certain size, it starts destroying the protective boundaries of the host community. Especially with importing already extant tribal and war torn societies, this is done with increased crime rates, as well as having their young warrior caste out wandering the streets. The protective boundary that formerly existed around the original community is shrunk down, at best, to the individual, which is hugely relationally destructive, and detrimental to social cohesion. And that leads to a scale-up of psychopathic behavior. Now instead of just working on an individual relational basis, the psychopathy becomes a group phenomenon. And in the case of Northern Ireland, with its long history of sectarian strife, this could lead to extremely unpredictable outcomes. And here’s the other thing. No one knows what those actual population sizes are that trigger violence, or nonlinear, deviant behavior. It’s a very dangerous, unpredictable game.

And make no mistake — the apparent pawns — the immigrant communities and their constituents — have no intention of staying pawns. So just because the virtue-signaling women have decided that they’re going to play a very deadly game of non-allegiance with their original communities doesn’t mean they’re not going to bring perdition down on all of us. Do remember — it’s partly a wild genetic, hardwired game. And the genes, and the psychopaths don’t care. The genes are playing the long game, for sure. But the psychopaths are playing as impulsive a short game as can be played.

And what could be more exciting than a good beheading?

The Memetics of Iran and the Great Decentralization

Two very cute noses

As I write this, Israeli and US bombs are dropping around Iran on various targets of the Islamic regime. It’s literally been a long time coming, and my opinion is that I hope like hell the Iranian people get a chance to be liberated from the pre-medieval Islamists. Our own Immiserator caste can only dream of the excruciating torture that the mullahs have made Iran endure over the last 47 years.

What is fascinating about all the surrounding confusion is the political alignments in the West that have grown up around the issue of removing the mullahs from power in Iran. Fresh out of the recent pro-Palestinian protests, you would think the Left across the Western world would be in the streets this morning, supporting the Iranian people. The mullahs are decidedly anti-woman, anti-free speech, and basically anti-anything resembling a free and decent society, by anyone’s standards. They want nuclear weapons, not just for some security chit, but because they want to use them against Israel. Various members of the Iranian elite have said as much over the last four decades.

Instead, what we get are a few, tepid demonstrations for the pro-Islamists around the globe. Seattle is having a manufactured protest this morning at Pike Place market. I’m sure more will be extant. But the mullahs are so repugnant an ally, not even the Left wants to smear too much of that defecation on themselves.

Here’s the point. At some level, political labels don’t stick very well to the Iranian situation. If it were women’s rights, or civilian deaths, the Left should be lining up with the general population of Iran. They aren’t, and they won’t. What this should tell us is that our widespread models of Left and Right are just not up to the task of explaining what is going on.

But if we dip our toes just a little into the memetic pool of understanding, looking at the situation from a v-Meme perspective, the reason the Left has even passing sympathy for the mullahs becomes apparent. The Islamic Revolution cohort are totalitarian globalists. They neurogenically match with the Left. They are not pro-Iranian, (just as our own Lefties are not pro-American), other than quite liking the fact that Iran is not some backwater of the Global South. It’s a fully equipped modern state, with universities, deep history, and beach houses on the Caspian Sea. If you’re going to hang out and wait for End Times, it beats the hell out of living in some sand-swept backwater, with a herd of camels at your doorstep. We don’t think of Iran like this — but it is one of the most beautiful countries in the region.

And that makes it a great place to wait. And did I forget to mention all that revenue from sales of oil? With superpower allies?

Some countries in the region have managed the delicate secular balance of being a Muslim nation, while maintaining a cultural identity. Tajikistan is an imperfect one. They banned the burqa, the Hijab, banned Prayer (Namaz) at public places, and the call to prayer (Azan) on loudspeaker, as well as child marriage. You can be a Muslim mostly in private, but you cannot force others in public to follow your prescriptions. The link above is a Tajik wedding dance.

The fact of the matter is the regime in Iran are actual globalists. They want a homogeneous Islamic State spread around the world. They don’t just want Iran. They want the whole enchilada. And the civilizational process necessary for them to get there is hardly any different from the globalists in the EU, or the declining caste in Washington, D.C. Globalists demand an elite. For the mullahs, it’s them. For the EU, it’s the gang in Brussels. And for the U.S., it’s more a country-wide movement, devoid of geography, but full of Woke. All three groups demand profound censorship. All three groups use immiseration as a tool to create a depressed population. All three groups are spearheaded by detached, bubbled up cohorts that believe in smashing dissent, and can’t understand why anyone would disagree with them. And if you do? It’s execution time. Our own Lefties are already plotting revenge, publicly, if and when they regain power. Susan Rice’s recent statement combines the new domestic D talking points with a deep desire for chaos. No exculpatory reading of the past for her.

Safe in their mountain kingdom, the Iranian mullahs don’t need to import more people in order to rig democratic processes for their agenda. That’s obviously not true in Europe and the U.S. The locals are waking up to the fact that they’re on the globalist’s menus. In the U.S., Biden and his Open Borders plan inflated the population of the U.S. by close to 10% to get those voting margins necessary for Leftie hegemony. Europe is in the process, but only after scandal after horrific scandal of immigrants mass-raping their women and children. The result of all this is that for the efforts toward globalization, which is really a centralization and homogenization operation intended to create the optimal psychosocial dynamics for a depressed population, ruled by some self-selected authoritarian overlords, knocks down the notion of culturally diverse nation-states. What it’s working to replace is any sense of agency and independently generated relationships inside those nations.

The problem is that once you do that — once you manage to functionally destroy Western civilization, either through Woke, or Islam, is you have a non-functional economic system. Modern economies are built on some version of trust. And if you cannot trust your neighbor, especially because they come from a low-trust culture, whose language nor mores you do not share, the best you’re going to end up with is a depressed polis, and tribal dynamics. If you don’t believe, look at all the scandals continuing to pour out of Minnesota. Minnesota is the bleak window into the future the Leftists envision as their response to the global Islamic state. And make no mistake — they are both competing for the same share of the memetic pie.

Into all this is the inevitable push-back from the nationalists. Trump in the US, Viktor Orban in Hungary, AfD in Germany, and one of my favorites, Eva Vlardingbroek in the Netherlands, are the vanguard for reclaiming their country from the globalists. As I’ve said before, they are champions in an orderly Great Decentralization, a coming-down from the dysfunctional utopian dreams of the globalists. For good or ill, our populations are simply not evolved enough for an unfettered, no boundaries global society. What we’re seeing now, with the endless flood of economic refugees from the Global South, Mexico and South Asia, is an uneven, but mostly negative patchwork of integration into already advanced cultures in the West.

The result of this is that informal governmental mechanisms, otherwise known as gangs and cartels, are occupying swaths of the geographic landscape in the Western nations. They operate in collusion with ostensibly legitimate governments in these places. But in order for them to exist, nominal, orderly services seem to not be able to. Looking at the Pacific Palisades neighborhood in L.A., still burned to the ground after last year’s fire, is the sign that the memetic pull from both the lack of sophistication and evolution, as well as cold, hard cash from illegal operations that elects incompetent politicians, is downward. These areas cannot recover, because there just aren’t enough smarts to restore even prime real estate.

If it reminds me of anything in my travels, it brings back memories of my trip to Greece. Greece is a nation with a stellar history — the birthplace of Western civilization. And the native people know it. But the streets suck, nothing really works very well, and the people, with their head cast down because they know of the greatness of their forebears, live in a combination of self-conscious, self-aware shame in all of it. How is it to truly know decline? Be the civilization that conquered the known world. And then has no suitable public sanitary facilities.

So what exactly is going on in Iran? The public uprising is really equivalent to all the movements around the world as an attempt for the people there to revive agency and move on the upward path of all civilizations. It is absolutely a re-nationalization effort. It is a populist movement. It is a freedom-of-information movement. It is a women’s liberation movement. And yes — it is revanchist, in that the temporary goal is to go back to Iranian society pre-1979. Witness the appearance of the Shah Pahlavi’s son as the figurehead.

Because where they are trapped now is in an Islamic globalist hell. Which at this point in time, leads back to tyranny. That train is never late. And make no mistake — the Western Left intends the same for us. Information control, 15 minute cities, driving restrictions through radical taxation, deprivation of relational freedom, and endless pointless rituals intended to make us all miserable — all are what’s on the menu. Think about that the next time you do a land acknowledgement.

You wonder what the Lefties have in common with the mullahs and radical Islam? Here’s hoping you now have your answer.

How to Start Understanding Psychopaths in Systems

Tango Show, Buenos Aires, 2013

One of the major challenges in understanding psychopaths in systems is that there is vanishingly little written on how such individuals work that can be believed. Most of the “hard” research done on psychopaths has been done on such individuals in prison settings. And the overwhelming body of literature emanating out of the True Crime genre makes one believe that every psychopath is a killer, and that is the end destination of anyone who is a psychopath. The problem with this worldview is one misses all the psychopaths that are non-criminal, and active in our daily lives.

Worse, from the work I’ve read, lots of work done on psychopathy has been done by psychopaths themselves. And while some of that may match one’s personal experience, a lot is done to throw people off the psychopath’s tracks. Think about it — why would any psychopath want to shed light on what might be their own downfall?

What I’ve written below is a summary from my analysis of the overall believable literature, and encompasses some of the definitions of DSM-V Axis II/Cluster B and C personality disorders. I lump all of this together because in the case of psychopaths in systems, the various differentiators are not particularly helpful, as they also can include extensive overlap. Someone who appears to have Antisocial Personality Disorder may also exhibit signs of Narcissistic Personality Disorder. And someone with strong Avoidant disorders may mask multiple behavioral traits that might link to more violent tendencies.

It is beyond the scope of this blog post to review comprehensively the individual characterization of people with personality disorders. Do your own research if you feel compelled. What this piece will do is reveal to you what I have discovered. I also know there is a powerful tendency (especially by psychopaths) for demanding “proof” — names of people I’ve learned these lessons from. That is also not going to happen. It’s easy enough to write about a mass murderer, because that person’s reputation is already ruined. But one thing I’ve learned about all the more ordinary, non-criminal psychopaths I’ve dealt with is that they are a litigious bunch. When you combine this with the willing volubility to lie, that means if you end up in court, you’re likely to lose. Most judges are authoritarian and egocentric, and this maps immediately into the psychopath’s wheelhouse. So no names or relationships. Make of what I write as you will.

If I had to lay down what I’ve discovered about most of the psychopathic personalities I’ve had to deal with, it might boil down to the following points:

  1. They are manipulative, projecting liars. They will often lie, and then project their desires on you while declaring themselves innocent.
  2. They have some version of an attachment disorder. They will be fascinated with a person, practice or object, until one day, they simply just drop that interest.
  3. In moments of excitement, they do not habituate to stimulus. This applies to if you’re hanging on a hook and they’re literally carving you up, or having wild sex. Enough is never enough. Until it is, of course.
  4. They are relationally disruptive, and especially so if in a circumstance where external societal forces are promoting some version of victimhood. Current “anti-racial discrimination” or feminist causes are chock-a-block full of psychopaths, who enjoy social endorsement for their natural tendencies.
  5. Linked to attachment disorders, they have poor object permanence. Things can simply stop existing in their lives on a whim.
  6. They have a poor sense of long-time consequences, and are exceptional in observing short-term spatial and temporal scales. For violent psychopaths, this allows them to literally get away with murder. If you killed someone, when it came to the crime scene, you’d likely miss something. Not a psychopath. The same tendency can favor certain disciplines like surgeons. The best surgeons can repeat the same surgery over and over again, as long as narcissistic supply is provided. And the last thing you want in your heart surgeon is him feeling your pain as he spreads your ribs.
  7. They have poor personal boundaries, which might drive their pathologies. This is also a source of their personal attractiveness, especially in romantic situations. Ego-merging is intoxicating until it isn’t. And the object of desire is left out in the cold.
  8. They can be, and often are charismatic, and are excellent at mirroring empathy.
  9. They can often only be detected through disturbance in the relational field around them.
  10. They cannot be understood nor behavior rationalized using the tools of normal human relational dynamics. In fact, attempts to rationalize how they act or react usually disables the healthy individual dealing with the psychopath. Their behavior does not follow a set of rules that normal humans follow.
  11. The best set of consistent narratives for understanding the various types of psychopathy is found in ancient myth archetypes. Sorcerers and sorceresses, vampires, shapeshifters, and various monsters all exist as humanity has struggled with various psychopaths through the ages.

The most important weapon in the systemic psychopath’s arsenal is the ability to grab the grounding circumstance for an individual, and then distort reality around that altered circumstance. This ability is called ‘gaslighting’, and explained here. The way this is occurs is through mirroring alignment by the psychopath with the target. The goal of the psychopath is to quite literally “get inside one’s head” through some emotional state matching and consilience of circumstance. Isolated individuals are obviously more susceptible than people in healthy communities. Sexual ego fusion is also a prime gateway. There’s a reason why the Chinese government (and governments past) used honeypots for conversion and betrayal of individuals toward their nation-state.

There are many techniques through using alignments of belief systems and mental models that psychopaths operate. Detection by an observer of manipulation depends on identifying top-level information that is either emotionally triggering or emotionally paralyzing, followed by a lack of information that delivers context for a given manipulative attack. In the recent onslaught against US Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE), a notable trope has turned into focusing on children attached to illegal aliens who have at least violated illegal entry laws, and often much worse. There is a societal propriety mechanism that says children should not be exposed to violence (even if they are) and makes discussion of individual cases mostly taboo. Yet the psychopath has no problem showing a picture of a child to establish control of the dialog. A great recent example is Liam Conejo Ramos, in a blue hat, who was being detained with his father after his father fled ICE agents outside his residence, and potentially refused custody with his mother. The situation is actually ambiguous. But the psychopath has no problem offering the ICE-condemnatory version up as proof that ICE needs to be defunded. Many such cases involving children being attached to parents in violation of immigration or other laws are used as psychopathic manipulation against DHS and ICE efforts.

This piece on hunger relief programs is a case study of how psychopaths use mental models to sabotage any reform of social services through deep-brain manipulation. As an example, the Democratic Party has used such techniques around the country to stonewall against reform of homelessness alleviation programs. If you take a program initially in line with a country’s values, like alleviating poverty, even after the problem is maximally solved (no societal problem can ever be completely put to bed) a good psychopath can continue the same manipulation strategy to pour money into their own coffers.

One of the key elements mentioned above regarding recognizing psychopaths in social systems is their use of relational disruption to sow chaos and allow them to gain control of situations and organizations. The way psychopaths work is not just directly instigating conflict between people. There is the metacognitive, “dark matter” effect, where organizations in chaos resolve into quiet when the psychopath is removed. People inside such an organization might behave in an aberrant or suppressed manner when a given psychopath is present, yet re-equilibrate to peace and harmony when that person is removed. In “A Primate’s Memoir“, Robert Sapolsky documented this transition in a baboon troop, where three aggressive, likely psychopathic baboons that ran a baboon troop died from eating refuse laced with bovine tuberculosis. After their passing, the remaining baboons basically stopped fighting and restored peaceful coexistence.

The usual result of having disruptive psychopaths in a given social network is actually a time-dependent trajectory. When a charismatic psychopath initially arrives, whether in a leadership or even in a lower level position, there is a flurry of relational disruption as the psychopath rearranges the topography of the social network. But over time, if disruption from the individual persists, human communities will functionally isolate the disruptor. Homeostasis returns, or collapse ensues.

Psychopaths have always been with us. The key to moving forward in an advanced society is to realize where they are at, and their impact. Only then can we alleviate the societal chaos they cause.

Virtue Signaling and Psychopathic Manipulation

Pearl Farm Platform Women — Misool, Indonesia

One of the newest terms to dominate the political lexicon is the term “virtue signaling” — which basically means communicating, especially to your in-group, but also to larger society, your views on issues that will somehow establish your status of possessing a deeper morality relative to those same groups. The old fashioned word for all this is some form of “piety establishment” — which is literally as old as the hills. It is used to project virtue that one typically doesn’t back up with any action, other than spouting off at others. Classic virtue signals are phrases like ‘Black Lives Matter’ or ‘Defund the Police’. The first is meaningless save as a racist attack for immiseration. The second is advocating a policy position, ostensibly for protecting poor people, but one which few poor people would agree with. Living in violent communities teaches you the value of good policing, needless to say.

What is interesting about both these statements is that they are classic examples of what is known as a ‘double bind‘ — an inherently contradictory statement that a given recipient cannot respond to conclusively, creating emotional paralysis. Applied liberally, it creates a destructive cognitive schizophrenia in the target, which then ungrounds the individual, and makes them easier to control.

Which makes it a natural tool of choice for psychopaths and those wishing to propagate psychopathic manipulation. And certainly, in a multi-level authoritarian hierarchy, becomes a convenient go-to for leaders of all stripes. Once you understand and ponder it, it’s not surprising that top politicians and CEOs both use, and succumb to it. When the dominant information replication technique is mirroring, there’s nothing better than a good old-fashioned virtue signal.

That also means that most virtual signals are on the top level of the knowledge structure stack — whatever obvious thing, with embedded tribal meaning, that can be manipulated in the form of a double bind. My absolute favorite has to be “Love is Love”. While there are some standard representations of love we are aware of, it can quickly be commandeered to justify any perversion the individual wishing to propagate to a larger audience. Note how such an argument is used to justify pedophilia. And as with all profound psychopathic manipulations, debate is immediately constrained to the source of the virtual signal. If you respond to the argument ‘Love is Love’ with the notion that it might not exactly apply across the board, you’ll be accused of being a pedophile yourself. This dovetails nicely with psychopathic projection, of course — getting accused of the sin the perp is actually contemplating.

A notable champion of this tactic had to be former Biden Press Secretary Karine Jean-Pierre. She would proudly proclaim her status as a lesbian in public press conferences. But if someone else discussed her lesbianism, and whether it might cast some doubt on her fitness as Press Secretary, that person would be immediately shouted down. I’ve noticed this with my own students — if a student declares themselves as Mexican or Hispanic, no one notices. But if I say something innocuous — like “what is the Mexican perspective on this issue?” — the collective student audience gasps. That’s how deeply embedded these techniques are in the contemporary psyche.

There might be virtue signals in higher level knowledge structures, but they are difficult to ascertain. Higher level knowledge structures usually are underlaid with a deeper “why”, and that complexity doesn’t easily transmit across larger groups. Additionally, higher level knowledge structures usually have some conditional elements, or situational circumstances. “Love is love” starts losing its punch when you start describing sidebars to the idea. It may become more truthful when you’re describing a BDSM orgy, but it loses its edge for confusion. And confusion is the main point.

Psychopaths love virtue signaling precisely because of its memetic transmissibility. And bored people are especially susceptible to it. Any good virtue signal has its roots in an emotional response that leads to that paralysis. So people without meaning or meaningful connection have an open socket in their brain waiting for a virtue signal to plug into. They can adopt the signal for their own, or they can join the ranks of Immiserators for which the virtue signal becomes a weapon. Societies grounded in some version of Survival mode are far less susceptible to virtue signaling. Because bullshit will get you killed.

Organized religion is not exempt from supporting virtue signals. The one thing that organized religion has going for it, though, is vetting of messages against deeper origination myths. The minute you end up with a larger stack behind any top level message, there is at least some hope for dilution of damage.

Deconstructing any given virtue signal is almost always trivial from a rational perspective. In the case of ‘defund the police’ — one might cite a couple of statistics about violent crime, or the actual opinions of poor people. The problem is that the virtue signaler’s thought originates in the limbic system of their brain, which is really a dichotomous processing center — things are either right or wrong. And that will inherently be tied to an emotional reaction, which is likely not going to be pleasant.

The other thing key in understanding psychopathic manipulation using virtue signals is that because of the way they work in the brain, expecting to tie the virtue signal to any sense of responsibility will also fail. The idea that if you broadcast publicly a particular thought, you then are tied into some plan of action to actually remediate the problem, other than participate in a large, group activity that reinforces the virtue signal, is not the case. Most virtue signaling is low responsibility, and once again, because it originates in the limbic system, has poor consequentiality tied to it. No one’s thinking about the downstream outcomes. And when you start bringing those up, you’re going to end up in a hole pretty quickly.

In summation, virtue signaling is a technique for manipulation and control, used primarily by affluent psychopaths. It’s “do as I say, as long as you think I’m great, and I don’t take any collateral damage” that characterizes most virtue signaling. And for those that want to pursue a broader meaning, look at Rob Henderson’s work on “Luxury Beliefs”.

The Great Decentralization

Braden on a wall, outside Las Vegas

In crazy times like now, some small cohort of people not swept up in the mania are scratching their heads, and saying “why is this happening?” We have a time in human history where wars (though they still exist) are few, technology is still making large advances (at least in certain sectors) and people are faced with unimaginable abundance. I look at my own experience with something as common as hard liquor as proof (no pun intended.) 40 years ago, buying a bottle of cognac was an unheard-of feat, and if you wanted selection, there were only a handful of stores in the country where you could find anything other than the primary brands of Hennessy or Courvoisier. Now, you can walk into almost any well-stocked liquor store and find dozens of brands. And don’t even go near the bourbon aisle. Hundreds of producers’ products line the shelves.

This explosion of selection directly maps to diversification in the information space. Whiskey is simple, of course — the financial incentive sprung up as people learned more about it, and as people indeed learned more about it, they started applying variations in taste, cocktails, and the proliferation of insights from the Internet to the problem. Such a supply is maintained only within the context of the information ecosystem that is created. If you have no insight or knowledge, you likely won’t lay out the money for a brand with no recognition. And it’s not long until that more complex ecosystem collapses, leaving you with just the bottom shelf in the liquor store.

All ecosystems are maintained under similar pretexts. Human societies are no different. Different societies have solved different versions of this problem of maintaining information complexity throughout time. I wrote earlier about how one of the first societies to run up against information complexity demands — China — managed this through the development of a professional class, primarily filled with autists, and screened by a complicated test on Chinese poetry, that allowed some modest social mobility. Anyone could take the test — but few would pass.

To reiterate — societies are maintained through quantity of reliable and valid information, with appropriate levels of information complexity, that when grounded in reality, allows that information to propagate across the society and be accepted as truth. Some level of validation of information by all participating members in a society is also necessary. Though not everyone in a given society can be responsible for knowing all truths, at least some of those truths must be verifiable, and tangible.

And herein lies the rub. Increasingly complex human societies (we are in one in the USA) require increasingly complex relational dynamics as well. It’s a closed loop — increasingly complex relational dynamics produce that information that the society needs to hold itself together. If those relational modes do not exist, no society, with a certain population quantity and density, can expect to hold together.

The memetic physics will tear it apart. Confusion will literally be its epitaph. Brainworms, or more specifically prions, is caused by cannibalism. It’s called Kuru. Here you go.

In a complex society, high levels of knowledge sophistication are demanded by the differentiated peoples in a given society. High levels of knowledge sophistication imply a fractal structure inside that knowledge, purely from the overlap of different circumstances that characterize any given member of that society. This knowledge inherently needs to be generated in two ways.

The first is by institutions in that society. The problem comes in with the structure of these institutions, and their robustness in the face of uncertainty. There is no way that all institutions can get all things correctly. But the problem exists that such institutions believe that they can. And if they have no fundamental epistemic humility, then far too often, the institutions will get things WRONG — and that destroys the faith that the larger body politic has in those institutions.

Further, institutions, due to their emergent hierarchical dynamics, as well as resource needs, will always be prone to capture by the powers-that-be. If the baseline guiding principles of a society are not egalitarian, with a commitment to upward social mobility and welfare of ALL its citizens, it won’t be long until these institutions are weaponized to advance the interests of elites inside a given society. I’ve written extensively about this. There is no better example than the COVID times, when elites ordered wholesale destruction of parts of the economy, and moved into servitude other parts, because of their paranoia of getting a virus that early on established itself as no threat (other than a bad flu) to the vast majority of the population.

This was dramatically reinforced by an entirely co-opted other caste — the various mainline journalistic institutions of our time — who sided with the elites in the various prescribed interventions. The various journalists and institutions piled award upon award against people who both committed crimes against humanity (like Tony Fauci) as well as the journalists who lionized them (e.g. Ed Yong.). Most of these people on the downstream side of the beneficiary equation still hold on to their power and privilege today. Elites may eat their own, but they never completely abandon them unless they’re on the dinner table. (See the discussion on Kuru above.)

We are now living in the after-times of these two historic institutional collapses — medicine, and journalism. The result for society is that we no longer have the information structure for easy recovery.

The second has to lie in development and appropriate development of agency, and its corollary in connection, empathy among its members. No society can completely rely on institutions, that can, and have been captured at various times by elites for various reasons, both nefarious as well as self-protective.

But in the last thirty years, especially, we’ve seen across-the-spectrum decay of both mission and execution of educating young people to the role of citizens that will both maintain the status quo of our country, as well as advance its interests and destiny. This lack of development will lead to follow-on consequences in time. We’ll have, percentage-wise, a larger and larger group of people who will inherit a large, complex machine, but will not know, nor understand the complexity consequences of pulling its various levers. The USA’s current population is somewhere in the neighborhood of 320 million people — its information quantity and complexity needs are immense. We are failing in so many ways, when we look to the basic literacy AND psychosocial maturity to run such an enterprise.

What the memetics tell us is that if we cannot generate the next class of people to inherit, tinker, and improve the current societal structures, then we will proceed down the social complexity ladder – the Great Decentralization. The Great Decentralization means that society must index itself to smaller scales, of people, space, and prosperity in order to be able to function coherently. The responsible government organs must scale down, in order to function at all — because the information flow into those organs cannot support a larger functioning scale. If you want a global society, it has to be composed of enough citizens who can operate at that scale. And so on down the track. We obviously do not have that at the current time. And that means society will downshift to generate political organs that operate without such corruption that makes homeostasis possible. National government doesn’t work? Step down to state government. State government doesn’t work? You get the idea.

The problem arises when you end up in a place where supra-scale informal organizations (like cartels) gain enough power and organizational control that they are competing with formal government bodies. This has already happened in Mexico, which by any definition is a failed state. It’s arguably happened in regions of the US along the Mexican border.

And psychopaths will drive that process. You don’t need to be a complex society to use a jet engine — but you definitely need one if you want to create one in the first place. So clever psychopaths will figure out how to disrupt those complex relational patterns to get us down where we’re feeling the pain. Short version — inspirational leaders take us up the complexity ladder. Psychopaths take us down.

What does ‘downwards’ really mean? We sit close to the apex of what a Performance-based/Legalistic society can be. Downwards means following the v-Memes — more Legalism, more Authoritarianism, and most importantly, especially for the two ends of the demographic age distribution, more Tribalism. The problem with this is that our wealth is NOT, as often condemned by our own corrupt intelligentsia, the result of colonial exploitation. It’s the result of innovation and hard work, by that group of individuals aged 20-60, which relies on advanced relational modes in order to keep going. These are the modes of independent relational development discussed ad nauseam on this blog. People must be able to meet other people (the whole freedom of association thing) and make their own decisions about whether to trust them or not. That trust, besides creating things like friendships, also vastly accelerates economic engines. Deals may have contracts, but if the contract is written up after the handshake, the ability to radically increase monetary tempo presents itself.

And when that collapses, first we lose the ability to support an elevated standard of living, which includes societal and social cohesion for people in this country. But worse — as we move back down the scale to overt Tribalism, we not only lose the standard of living. We lose the ability to support the people here in the first place.

The way societies re-equilibrate after such social decay is mass death. A great recent example of this is the Hutu-Tutsi genocide in Rwanda. Short version — after the two sides killed off 10-15% of the population, and drove out another 20%, peace returned, and now Rwanda is stable. It is hard for people to wrap their heads around loss of 30% of the population of the country. Such large numbers, contrary to belief, do not scale well inside the heads of most people. The short version is this — it is a full-on massacre.

All this sets the stage for smaller governance structures, inside smaller populations of humans. The Internet has scrambled much of this through the Death of Geography. Now, more than ever, it is easier to fall into a variety of tribes NOT based on geography, but instead, built on memetic foundations. You can find who you agree with far more easily. But that is not in the interest of the psychosocial development of our own country. Finding people who you instantly agree with doesn’t force relational growth. And with the Left’s declaration of being a law unto themselves, now if you are a compromiser, you end up in the ‘outcast’ category. That elevates the Immiseration class, and overall unhappiness is never in the interest of productivity.

The last presidential election was a huge moment in the Great Decentralization, in that a voter received an opportunity to choose one of two paths towards how this might happen. One the one side was the Democratic candidate, who promised “more of the same”. But what was more of the same? As we are now finding out, the secret coalition that drove much of Democratic politics in the last four years was centered around federal budgets diverted to serving the NGO-DEI-Industrial Complex, driven on the surface by LGBTQ activists and various absurdist social issues, like trans-ing children (which further disqualified the institutional veracity of the medical community) as well as funding the dumping of illegal aliens into the US. During the Biden years, through illegal immigration, population increased somewhere between 8%-10%. No real attempt was made regarding fiscal responsibility, or even any understandable larger economic policy for the country. In short, the Democratic path toward decentralization was going to be collapse and anarchy. And somehow, the elites in this country, virtue signaling all the way, were going to come out on top of all of it.

On the other side was the loosely held coalition of MAGA, true centrists, and cast-offs from the political Left that had gotten to the point of not being able to stomach the various unhinged dogmas generated by the radical Left of the Democratic Party. This coalition had at its front Donald Trump, a moderate Republican, whose claim to fame was abrasive authenticity. Trump declared his path to decentralization as one focused on removal and shrinkage of the larger federal government, as well as removal of the 10% of the illegally imported population, demographically targeted to win elections in swing states that were augmented during the Biden years, in order to change seat allocation in the House of Representatives.

As I chose whom to vote for, foremost in my mind at this fork in the road, I was, and am still concerned about environmental issues and young people — my two primary political foci. I came to the conclusion that a Harris/Walz administration would be far worse for both. Regarding environmental issues, a Harris/Walz ticket would likely spawn a new Cabinet office dedicated to manipulation of the public over Anthropogenic Global Warming (AGW), with tons of money being diverted from the government into Degrowth philosophies. And that would harm the second primary concern of my politics — the future of young people.

Lest ye think I was naive, I knew that the Republican Party would still engage in their own historic excesses, of handing out favors to its mainline political supporters. But that’s a devil, policy-wise that I did know, and knew how to fight.

What has surprised me about the Great Decentralization is two-fold. First is the uncovering of the vast NGO-funded mechanisms that were already extant in the federal government that I was unaware of. The short version was that the federal government had already handed off, through some version of direct aid or block grants, vast governmental real estate to the states, under the aegis of charity and social services. With most of the standard federal oversight mechanisms removed, these funds immediately became captured, both legally and illegally, by supporters of the Left. The Somali daycare scandal is a hallmark, though I believe we will discover much more fraud throughout the social welfare system as time goes by.

The second has been the emergence of the anarchist/chaos-bent Left, whose response to being defunded on all fronts has led to chaotic violence in the name of First Amendment protest, and high-profile societal disruption. The Minnesota insurgency against ICE is a premier example, though as this piece is being written, evidence is coming to light that there have been multiple conspiratorial networks, based on the same organizational structures, being erected across the United States.

All is not yet lost. It’s important to remember and realize that even the ICE protests in Minneapolis are geographically limited, and their presence is causing tremendous economic harm to local constituents. Such harm serves as a deterrent for other municipalities with disruptive entities to double down on promoting the chaos, as Minnesota elected officials have done. And while it looks like the anti-ICE actions have potential for being nationally contagious (figuring out the racket is always the first challenge of conspirators) as time goes on, it seems increasingly unlikely, save as screaming about it as a potential election issue. Talk is, as it always is, cheap. And far better than facing a RICO rap, which I expect we’ll see coming down the pike for individuals like MN Lt. Governor Peggy Flanagan, who actively participated in the Signal network for tracking and doxxing ICE agents.

The Great Decentralization, however, will continue. There is (outside my ridiculous blog) poor understanding of the social physics, or even acknowledgement that such social physics even exist. And until we can talk about root cause — which directly gets to the issue of psychosocial developmental issues across society, such as how to build identity and responsibility for larger society inside its citizenry, we are stuck on the lowest energy path for a society.

And that ain’t pretty.

Memetic Conflict and Perceived Moral Order

North Fork Clearwater, Idaho, Drone Shot

One of my favorite pieces of mental work that I figured out in the old noggin is this piece here — the origins of memetic conflict that happens when different value systems collide. In order to completely grok it, you’re going to have to read a little about v-Memes — it’s not that hard. But the short answer is that when different societies, based on different social structures, run into each other over contested ground, how evolved those systems are will definitely decide the outcome.

The short version is that in the classic Spiral Dynamics progression of societies — Survival, Tribal, Authoritarian, Legalistic, Performance-Based, Communitarian and on into the Second Tier — misunderstanding and conflict will depend on the memetic spacing of levels between the two conflicting social structures. Two levels (e.g. between Tribal and Legalistic) will result in Incomprehension — the two systems cannot understand each other. Three levels? What I describe as the Insanity/Barbarism conflict, which is what is happening currently in the conflict over ICE in Minnesota.

Here’s the social structures from Don Beck as a refresher.

Through a complicated path, mostly committed by psychopaths seizing control of dominant foundational myths in the Lefty Noosphere, the current Democratic Party has reverted primarily to Tribal knowledge structures. That drives emergent focus on Donald Trump as some version of The Great Satan, and a pathology across Lefties of all stripes, but especially their intellectual caste, with what is called Trump Derangement Syndrome (TDS). The justification for TDS is honestly monotonous, and is an exemplar of how higher knowledge structures that may have been present in individuals, necessarily simplify and rigidify when downconverted into Tribal forms. Trump is evil, Trump is corrupt, Trump is buddies with Epstein and a pedophile, and so on. No amount of context can derail this myth structure, other than the Left being forced to recognize that Trump is still President.

This is powerful when coded into some form of exchangeable morality — numerous folks don’t have to know much to “virtue signal” — communicate to others in the tribe their status through ostensible piety, of these foundational myths. It IS true that most of these Tribal myths are all centered around “Trump as a dishonorable, evil man.” The problem is that the world is a more complex place than whether you hate Donald Trump or not. And to some extent, the Republicans aren’t helping much, either. The current Republican administration is hardcore Performance/Goal-Based thinking. The one thing that matters is getting done whatever the governing item is. And Trump engages in constant negotiations with his adversaries, obviously due to his background as a New York real estate mogul.

This comes off as absolutely insane to the Lefty In-group/Out-group Tribalists, who, with poor consequential thinking, cannot perceive how they’ve been co-opted by their parasitic psychopath class, who had prior to Trump and Elon Musk showing up, had established a rich vein of revenue through exploitation of face-value virtue-laden topics that the majority of their base had lapped right up. “USAID is saving starving kids in Africa!” is one of my favorites. Why? I worked for USAID in Egypt, and had the surreal opportunity of seeing how they actually worked. I was window dressing for some competing ruling faction in Egypt at the time, supposedly working on a fertilizer plant control system, which then was one of the projects providing cover for the deep political machinations going on, facilitated by political US meddling. The end result of which was the Arab Spring, one of the original Color Revolutions, which did not quite go the way we planned.

The larger Republican Party is not completely Performance-based. There are still components that have strong Authoritarian bents (the Christian Right) as well as a large institutional caste of actors, named along with their Democratic counterparts, the Deep State, occupying the Legalistic v-Meme. If the Republicans seem diffuse as far as worldview, it’s because they are. While the Democrats are spiraling out of control on pure Tribalism, the Republicans face a queasy coalition centered around less government and traditional government favors to corporations and businesses. Which is problematic, because while the Democrats can coalesce around absolutely insane myths, like gender identity is only determined by how a person feels today. And because of their simplicity, these information structures are truncated, based on emotional appeal and very viral.

And so we end up in the current disaster in Minneapolis. In the last few weeks, two “activists” have been shot and killed. Theoretically, these “activists” are somehow nonviolent Legal Observers and merely traveling around after ICE and documenting arrests made by ICE. The videos of what actually is happening, and other recent disclosures regarding their organization, do, in no way shape or form, support any of this. The activists are extremely well-organized and coordinated in a network where individuals are dispatched via the messaging app Signal to tail ICE vehicles, and upon arriving on the scene, disrupt ICE arrests of illegal immigrants. When they arrive, they act literally like insane monkeys on meth, often closing distance with ICE agents face-to-face, while blowing whistles and horns. With the recent information regarding Signal app organizing, it is my belief that they could actually be considered a criminal conspiracy, subject to Racketeering Influence and Corrupt Organizations Act (RICO) sanctions.

Of course, the PROBLEM is within the context of their Tribal situation, sprinkled with fragmented myths about Constitutional function, is that they don’t perceive themselves as a criminal operation. Self awareness is pathetically low. And that is deeply problematic when dealing with the outside world. The second person shot, Alex Pretti, a 37 year old ER nurse — far past the age to rationalize this kind of behavior with youthful ignorance, showed up for his round in the “chase the ICE agents and harass them” sporting a handgun — a Sig Sauer 9mm. One of the unbreakable rules in my world, when I was helping run a large civil disobedience campaign, was NO GUNS. You don’t have guns at a protest, because if things go south, and sometimes they do, LEOs can kill you legally. And then you’re dead.

This particular type of Sig Sauer also has a handling misfire problem, and if dropped, can go off. It’s also no surprise to me that it was an ER nurse who made such a bad judgment call. ER staff were the worst of the COVID alarmist crowd, and there’s also no question that trauma can stack up and cause erratic reactions in stressful situations. Immediately, the propaganda side on the Left seized on the notion that Alex had a legal concealed carry permit, and in the classic distortion of thought that is haunting the Left nowadays, put that in the blender and came out with “ICE needs to adapt their tactics to support Legal Observers’ Second Amendment rights to carry hand guns into violent situations and conflicts with ICE officers.” Are you kidding me?

Even while they’re acting like meth-crazed monkeys. I watched the videos involving the incident where the gun went off (my guess is likely a misfire) and then what happened is what can happen in any LEO arrest scenario. Once the cop thinks either he or his buddy is under threat from a firearm, the cop will proceed to empty their clip into the suspect. Which usually means a dead perp. Much was also made in this Lefty propaganda round about how he was defending a woman “activist/Legal observer.” The clip I saw didn’t include the prior where she got into it with the ICE agents. But I’ve been in enough situations to know that a certain subset of women will fly off the handle, and believe they are the reincarnation of an invincible Valkyrie, and aggressively attack even LEOs. Call it the Mama Bear Social Control response. I even trained my two sons, now ages 25 and 27, when they were 16 and 18, what to do in a situation with potential law enforcement involvement (say a fight at a party.). They are both strapping young lads, and they both know that they are supposed to grab their girlfriends and run like hell, preferably before the cops show up. And if the girlfriend is dancing on his arm, screaming about her honor, and won’t leave — then ditch her. Cops will always threat-assess, and my two sons are 6’3″ and 6’5″. Which means one is going on the bumper with the bracelets, and the other is going in the backseat of the cruiser. The cop is not going to care about any dancing fairy princess.

Once again, the arguments from the Left to support their position are the result of projection and supposition — perceived moral order. Not validity grounding with anything resembling reality. I think it’s hard to understand this completely. I think a lot of the people involved in the obstruction of ICE in MN are likely middle-class, and have little to no experience with law enforcement. So they view themselves as White Knights, endorsed by their communities, and encouraged by local and state leadership in these actions. They view that because these various state and local officials have endorsed their moral position, and said they are brave and courageous, that somehow these ostensibly powerful people will rescue them. Little do they realize that their distorted sense of morality has no real power in a federal courtroom. And the other key fact is that they also are patsies ripe for disavowal by exactly those same individuals.

And what to think of the state and other government officials encouraging the insurrection? They’re locked in a deal with utter personal destruction once all is revealed. There’s tons of Somali daycare and medical service fraud that it is simply impossible to believe local and state officials either ignored, or were directly on the take. Fraud in Blue States is going to be an emergent issue in the coming New Year. While the Minnesota cabal, including Tim Walz and his lieutenant governor, Peggy Flanagan, seem to be mostly passively raking in the cash, and NOT involving the crazy gangland violence on the US southern border, it still means that this will be certainly the end of their political careers and inflated standard of living (Walz has already stepped down from running in the next election.)

But there are larger implications nationally. It’s through a glass darkly on what has been going on in our western southern tier, whose political caste is thoroughly intertwined with far more malevolent actors than the displaced Somali pirates in Ohio and Minnesota. You don’t have to stretch the Overton Window too far to see how the CIA facilitated Somali immigration, starting in the ’90s. But most of what came across the southern border during Joe Biden’s disastrous presidency came courtesy of the Sinaloan and other cartels. Walz and his crooked cohort may just end their lives in the big house. But that’s not the same for the various political forces across California, Arizona, New Mexico and Texas. The cartels are fond of torture and execution. And the Pandora’s box of inflated human trafficking revenue that happened through the betrayal of the Biden administration, and in particular Alejandro Mayorkas, has collapsed. No real natural born killer is going to take that lying down. The cockroaches are going to eat themselves.

Getting back to the primary point of this piece — the Left has left itself open to destruction in the context of memetic understanding by viewing the current administration as insane. They’re not. The problem is the flip side of the memetic conflict is that the Right views them as barbarians, which is decidedly not how the Left views themselves. The Left better get over its fascination with its self-generated moral order, and quick. The federal government, as well as most of the country, is nowhere near the point of collapse. And while the Left may not view themselves that way, the Trump administration, especially in the context of its goal-oriented focus of clearing out illegal aliens doesn’t give a shit about their moral order. They possess the reins of law and order on their side. And in the end, law and order are popular with the general population.

And as the effects of brainwashing using permission structures, started by David Axelrod and Barack Obama, wash off, my bet is no one is going to give a damn about the ginned up Lefty moral order that was potentially not created, but certainly accelerated, during the fractured COVID years. And grounding back to reality is brutal. It involves arcing.

And that means someone is going to get severely burned.

Why Won’t the Left Support the Iranian Revolution?

Stradivarius, Florence, Italy

Why won’t the Left in the United States support the current citizen’s revolution in Iran? If we want to understand why, we have to realize that all these actions occur in The Matrix, as well as on the top level.

A brief update. Approximately a week ago, across Iran, massive public demonstrations have been held against the mullahs and the Islamic Republic. The deeper history locates the start in Iran’s Kurdistan, in the town of Saqqez, centered on the death of a young woman, Mahsa Amini, after detention by Iran’s morality police in Tehran in 2022. The protests have bubbled along for awhile, but exploded last week across Iran. Though the collapsing economy certainly primed the pump, the treatment of women by the Islamic Republic’s mullahs have driven the moral compass on efforts to overthrow the current regime.

As I’ve written in this piece, Iran is not a ‘downstream tribal’ nation like Saudi Arabia. The population is split into multiple cultural and memetic groups, which range from tribal peasants to modern-day Performance-based liberals. Iran has some of the trappings of a Performance-based Communitarian society, in that its defense programs are likely the most advanced of any Third-World-esque outlaw nation. You don’t invent nuclear weapons nor sophisticated drones without the ability to have advanced social organization. And advanced social organization requires people to possess their own minds — agency.

In the wake of the bombings of the nuclear weapon Fordow and Natanz sites, less reported were other casualties of Israel’s and Iran’s 12 Day War (June 13-June 25, 2025) and Israel’s destruction of key centers of the Islamic Republic’s military ‘civilian suppression’ units. The Thar Allah Corps, Delman Corps, Special Unit in Khavoran, and the Imam Hassan Alborz Corps were four firebases stationed around Tehran to attack the local populace in the case of unrest and uprising. Because of their consolidation during the war — all members reporting in — Israel launched major attacks and basically killed the mullahs’ population suppression shock troops, creating prime conditions for a revolution. As this is being written, the mullahs are attempting to import Arab jihadis from Iraq and Syria to fill in these roles. It is not clear whether they will succeed (I expect Israeli intervention in any kind of mass airlift) but my guess is they will not.

It is important to understand, at least a little, why Islamic regimes are inherently anachronistic and incapable of long-term persistence. Iran long ago left being a Tribal v-Meme society (look at the long history of empires in its cultural record) and was, during the latter part of the 20th century, moving into the meme set of a Legalistic/Performance-based democracy. But this evolutionary progression simply got too far ahead of its leadership — Reza Shah was historically an autocrat and elite, and armed with Savak, a feared secret police, as well as a large peasant caste that was mired back in the Middle Ages. The result was that the regime collapsed, with some help, as well as disinterest from Western forces, and the mullahs took over. Organization and social evolution will always carry the day.

The problem with the level of psychosocial development of any hard core Islamic republic is that Islam, in its core beliefs, is stuck in Tribal/Authoritarian hegemony. Mental models are unchanged literally across centuries. And that means they’re primed to be taken over by psychopaths — which is what happened. Ceilinged out in complicated legalism, the individual has no agency in the face of the mullahs. And there is no allowance for individuals to develop in empathy past what the mullahs will allow. And Islam is very clear about maintaining second-class citizenry for those that don’t fall under the mullahs’ aegis. Don’t believe? Read about Jizya here — the dominant Somali mindset in the current set of fraud scandals in Minnesota.

All this might last for a long time in a pre-modern world (and did.). But influences from the outside are irresistible in the world of the Internet. When the signs of 21st century prosperity are only a click away, and one also gains the ability to broadcast your own plight to that world outside the mullah’s hegemony, regardless what happens with this revolt, the mullahs are living on borrowed time. Ask not who the Death of Geography comes for.

That doesn’t mean that blood will not be spilled. The various military organs of the Islamic State may be more than decimated — but they are not completely gone. And they have far more guns than the urban populations they are up against. A key noted element is whether the Army will refuse to shoot their own civilians, and turn toward the monarchists. We’ll see. I think the Army will turn — because the regime is driving the economy into the ground, and in the end, armies run on money.

So why, then, does the Left seem at best indifferent towards the mass protests in Iran? There is no memetic resonance between the conformance-demanding Left and the desire by the urban Iranian populace for more agency. In fact, it’s anathema. The Sophisticated Left — the Left that has some background knowledge on global affairs — keeps attempting to stand up organizations and agencies similar to what the mullahs have already created. Disinformation policing, messaging rigidity, moral condemnation of non-believers, and funding of special castes are the core of Leftist philosophy. All that’s left to differentiate is a call to prayer five times a day. The v-Meme matching between the punitive legalism and endless categorization of most of the Left in the Western world, and the destructive prescriptions of the mullahs meta-matches. Sure — they disagree on the top level (e.g. ‘treatment’ for homosexuality in Iran involves real conversion therapy — castration, though on second thought, maybe they’re not that physically far apart) but these are minor details. The deep structure of knowledge lines up, regarding who gets to dictate what people think, and who must be punished if their thought just doesn’t line up with the orthodoxy.

The last thing the Left wants to do is amplify the message of more agency. Much has been made about how various young people in the U.S. flocked to the Palestinian protests, and the assumption made was that those young people must have deeply understood the issue. Give me a break. The Palestinian protests were a social relief valve for young people deprived of 3 years of their social development by COVID restrictions. Protest movements were always a great way to get laid, and if you think no one was having sex in those tent cities, you don’t spend much time around post-adolescent adults.

For those that actually know what’s going on, the messages out of Iran are even more powerful against the Left. Iranians as a whole are exhausted with their government’s endless military adventurism across Iraq, Syria and Palestine. They’re the ones under Israel’s bombs, and what the urban class wants is NOT hyperinflation (the Rial, the Iranian currency has undergone something like 1000x inflation in the last 20 years) but some return to a modest prosperity that those of their educational caste have grown to expect. Iranians are very good at secret societies — this comes from literal 1000s of years of dealing with invaders. But by current global world trade standards, no one economy can exist today without trading with its neighbors. This notwithstanding the modest stream of supplies passing through Dubai, and on its way to Bandar al Abbas on the other side of the Persian Gulf.

And as I wrote in this piece, memetically the Left is profoundly wed to collapse. This made them natural allies with Hamas and their suicidal attack on Israel on October 7, 2023. But the current zeitgeist of the Iranian resistance is far more akin to MAGA — more of a ‘Make Iran Great Again’ mindset. People are literally yelling in the street they don’t care about Israel OR Palestine.

The current figurehead of the Iranian resistance is Shah Reza Pahlavi II — who before he was exiled in 1979, used to fly an F-14 in the Iranian Air Force. Information is sparse on him, honestly. I have a bias against any Pahlavi– they have a notorious reputation in my own family toward killing my family members. But I’m going to hold out hope that if the Revolution is successful, that we will see a receding monarchy after order is established. I’m pretty sundered from the remainder of my relatives in Iran, but I can tell you that all the engineering scholars in the US have no desire to go back. And they are not going to get caught in a group of immigrants condemning America. They know what’s at stake.

This is an ever-evolving situation. I’m going to pray for the Iranian people. No one in the world has a corps of first-class Immiserators like the IRCG and the Islamic regime, and the Iranian people have suffered enough. They serve as a cautionary note if we let our own AWFULs get out of control. And I’d argue that it is the Iranian people’s time. They deserve to be free.

But as we know all too well, deserve’s got nothing to do with it.